Family owned since 2014 Budd Lake & Morristown NJ
Small Batch Gourmet Ice Creams
We proudly churn all of our small batch ice creams and vegan dessert on premises. Our mission is to create unique flavor combinations that lift your spirits and seduce your imagination. We rely on using locally sourced ingredients as often as possible and creating many flavors and textures in house.
Banana Oreo
Real banana ice cream loaded with chocolate sandwich cookies
0
Birthday Bash!
The winning flavor to celebrate Mount Olive's 150th Anniversary! Birthday Bash is a yellow cake ice cream loaded with sprinkles and birthday frosting Thanks, Caitlin L for the suggestion!
0
Black Raspberry
Velvety smooth, fruity, and perfectly sweet black raspberry ice cream
0
Breakfast with Mayor Joe
0
Butter Pecan
An ice cream shop classic! Smooth buttery ice cream with roasted pecans. *contains Pecans*
0
Cheri Vanilla
Our vanilla ice cream loaded with dark cherry halves and beautiful pink cherry swirls
0
Chocolate
Our dark chocolate ice cream features single origin, fair trade chocolate from Venezuela
0
Chocolate Cake
A chocolate lover's dream! Chocolate ice cream with thick fudge swirls and chocolate crunchies mixed throughout.
0
Chocolate PB Cup
Dark chocolate ice cream with chunks of Reeses peanut butter cups and thick swirls of peanut butter. A truly indulgent ice cream We take extra precaution to serve peanut butter ice creams safely including the practice of using peanut butter specific scoops to serve the ice cream *contains Peanut Butter*
0
Coconut
Coconut flakes in a coconut ice cream
0
Coffee
A bold dark roast coffee ice cream
0
Colombian Cookies n Cream
An all time fan favorite! Colombian coffee ice cream with cookies
0
Cookies n Cream
Vanilla ice cream loaded with cookies
0
Cookie Dough
Cookie dough bits and pieces mixed throughout our vanilla ice cream.
0
Cotton Candy
Cotton candy is a perfect mix of sweet, fruity, and fun!
0
Downton Abbey
Dark chocolate ice cream with caramel swirls and bits of English Toffee *contains Almond*
0
Fig
A delightful combination of creamy vanilla ice cream and caramel swirls with real figs
0
For the Sage of Maple
A unique combination of maple ice cream with candied walnuts and sage *contains Walnuts*
0
Grahamsterdam
Marshmallow and graham mixed throughout vanilla ice cream. Top it off with some hot fudge and whipped cream to create your own s'mores sundae! *contains egg*
0
Kulfi, Toasted Coconut Almond
A caramelized coconut ice cream with toasted coconut flakes and almonds. Kulfi is a traditional style of making ice cream in India. *contains Almonds and Coconut*
0
Mint Chip
Classic smooth mint ice cream with dark Belgian chocolate chunks
0
Orange Mist
Our citrusy grapefruit ice cream with orange peel
0
Raspberry Cheesecake
Cheesecake ice cream with jammy raspberry swirls
0
Rocky Road
Deep chocolate ice cream with almonds and ribbons of marshmallow *contains Almonds and egg*
0
Strawberry
Real strawberry ice cream
0
Strawberry n Cookies
A vanilla ice cream with strawberry swirls and a medley of cookies folded in. Reminiscent of strawberry shortcake!
0
★ Triple Chocolate Stout
The malty, toasty, bitter, and slightly burnt tastes characteristic of a chocolate stout shine through the dark chocolate in our ice cream. Made with real Chocolate Stout beer. Contains barley
0
Vanilla
We make our vanilla with a double fold Madagascar vanilla. Double fold means twice the quantity of vanilla beans are used to make the same amount of a single-fold extract. The resulting ice cream is a vanilla second to none
0
Vanilla PB Chunk
Vanilla ice cream with chunks of Reeses Peanut Butter Cups and peanut butter ribbons. We use peanut butter specific scoops in a separate dipping well to serve our peanut butter ice cream, always keeping your food allergies in mind.
0
Vegan and Dairy Free Flavors
Our vegan desserts are coconut milk based and flavored with only plant based ingredients such as fruits, vegetables, herbs, and extracts. Our sorbets are fruit based and vegan! Scara's Italian Ices are refreshing dairy, peanut, tree nut, and gluten free choices Our Vegan flavors are free of major tree nuts including: walnuts, almonds, pecans, cashews, pistachios, and hazelnuts
Vegan Black Cherry
Our vegan coconut milk frozen dessert made with Oregon black cherries and only plant based ingredients. Try this or any vegan flavor blended with oat milk for a vegan shake!
0
Vegan Chocolate
Dark, decadent, and dairy free! Our coconut milk frozen dessert is made with dark cacao powder and only plant based ingredients. Try this or any dairy free flavor blended with oat milk for a vegan shake!
0
Vegan Mint Oreo
Our coconut milk frozen dessert is made with vegan mint flavor and dairy free, vegan cookies
0
Scara's Lemon Italian Ice
A refreshing lemon ice
0
Scara's Rainbow Italian Ice
A trio of the most popular Italian Ice flavors! Cherry, Lemon, and Blue Raspberry. Dairy Free.
0
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Soft Vanilla
Rich, sweet, and creamy classic soft serve vanilla ice cream
0
Soft Chocolate
Smooth soft serve chocolate ice cream
0
Twist
The best of both worlds! A twist of vanilla and chocolate soft serve ice creams
0
Toppings
Rainbow Sprinkles
0
Chocolate Sprinkles
0
Hot Fudge
0
Caramel Sauce
0
Marshmallow Sauce
0
Peanut Butter Sauce
0
Strawberry Sauce
0
Pineapple Sauce
0
Chocolate Syrup
0
White Chocolate Drizzle
0
Chocolate Shell/Chocolate Dip
0
Whipped Cream
0
Gummy Bears
0
Chocolate Chips
0
M&Ms
0
Coconut Flakes
0
Maraschino Cherries
0
Fresh Banana
0
Heath Bar Crumbles
contains Almond
0
Reese's Peanut Butter Cup chunks and crumbles
contains milk and peanuts
0
Almonds
0
Pecans
0
Peanuts
0
Dry Walnuts
0
Wet Walnuts
Walnuts in syrup
0
Brownie Bits
0
Cookie Dough Bits
0
Graham Crumbs
0
Chocolate Cake Crunch
0
Broken Oreo Cookies
0